phabricator replies by e-mail issue coming from noreply@phabricator.whonix.org

[phabricator-migrator]

Information

ID: 674
PHID: PHID-TASK-awglbydft5uso7vtmlzo
Author: Patrick
Status at Migration Time: invalid
Priority at Migration Time: Normal

Description

@dau had some issues. See T659#13168.

I am getting mails from:

phabricator+T659+randomstring+randomstring@phabricator.whonix.org

phabricator e-mail replies work for me.

@dau is getting mails from:

noreply@phabricator.whonix.org

Therefore replies by e-mail don’t work.

Any idea? @fortasse

Comments

---

fortasse

2017-05-07 15:05:35 UTC

The From: and Reply-to: headers should be different. The From: noreply@phabricator.whonix.org is expected. @dau, what does your Reply-to: header say?

I suspect this is a mail client issue, I haven’t made any changes to phabricator’s mail configuration.

---

dau

2017-05-09 03:22:03 UTC

Correct, I receive notifications from noreply@phabricator.whonix.org. The reply was indeed sent

To: phabricator+T659+randomstring+randomstring@phabricator.whonix.org

and

In-Reply-To: 86597b9685976b1e05d10fc75f89ed83@localhost.localdomain

Also, my mail client is mutt.

Thanks!

---

fortasse

2017-05-09 12:10:06 UTC

I think it’s because you started with a quoted line. I’m testing this
theory now.

---

fortasse

2017-05-09 12:11:01 UTC

This is an email reply with a “quoted” first line

And here is a regular line

---

fortasse

2017-05-09 12:20:58 UTC

How very odd. This is apparently a known issue upstream: ⚓ T5181 Parse in-line replies in email responses.

Apparently my fake quoted line doesn’t break it since it’s not an actual quote? I’m very confused, but I guess it’s not very high priority for upstream to fix.

---

dau

2017-05-13 12:42:20 UTC

Was the text you sent exactly the following?

> This is an email reply with a "quoted" first line

And here is a regular line

Well, at least personally I do not think it’s a high priority issue as well. I’m fine by using the web interface. Should we schedule a reminder to ask them about it or something like that?

---

Patrick

2018-12-09 05:55:07 UTC

Please reopen if still an issue.